PDA

View Full Version : Plum Creek Deal



weary
10-27-2006, 11:10
AMC and the Nature Conservancy have cemented the deal announced a few months ago in which they earn the right to buy easements and lands if Maine approves a giant Plum Creek development in the Moosehead Lake region.

In my opinion the deal virtually assures approval of the development. It provides an important buffer for the Appalachian Trail, and a terrible blow to those of us who favor keeping the Maine wildlands wild.

Here's the story:

The Nature Conservancy said Tuesday it has agreed to pay Plum Creek Timber Co. a total of $35 million to preserve 345,000 acres of northern Maine forestland and create the nation's second-largest conservation easement.

Plum Creek joined the Nature Conservancy and two other conservation groups last March in announcing agreement on a "framework" to protect forest land in the Moosehead Lake region through purchases and easements. The permanent conservation hinges on whether Plum Creek is allowed to develop two resorts and 1,000 homes in the Moosehead area.

The plan is currently before the Land Use Regulation Commission, which has been waiting for the details on the conservation deal.

The deal has been controversial because some say it will pressure the public and the commission to accept development that will change the character of the Moosehead region.

Under the agreement announced Tuesday, the Nature Conservancy, the Appalachian Mountain Club and the Forest Society of Maine have five years from the date of LURC's approval of the concept plan to raise the funds needed to acquire parcels or easements on nearly 345,000 acres. A total of 270,000 acres would be protected by a no-development easement.

"The agreement means we can conserve vast stretches of forest near Moosehead Lake, protecting forest-products jobs, natural resources and public access, including hunting, fishing, hiking, backcountry and motorized use," said Mike Tetreault, executive director of the Nature Conservancy.

"With these purchases, Maine will have established a contiguous stretch of a million and a half acres of conserved lands stretching westward from Baxter State Park and northward to the St. John River."

While the purchases are contingent on LURC approval of the Plum Creek concept plan, neither the Nature Conservancy nor the two other conservation groups has taken a position on the plan itself.

The nation's largest conservation easement became a reality in 2001 with the closing of a $28 million deal to protect more than 762,000 acres of Pingree family forest land in Maine.


Portland Press Herald story submitted by Weary

map man
10-28-2006, 00:03
For those like me who don't know Maine that well, I looked it up in an atlas and the southern-most shore of Moosehead Lake is a 15 mile drive mostly north and a little west from Monson. Do you know, Weary, exactly where the land in question is (both the proposed development and the area with the conservation easement)? How close to the AT? And how visible the proposed development would be from high view-points on the AT in the vicinity?

TJ aka Teej
10-28-2006, 00:08
There's one on this site:

http://www.plumcreekplanmaine.com/news/

map man
10-28-2006, 00:28
Thank you, Teej. Looks like a section of conservation easement in the very southeast part of this area is what is closest to the AT, and it looks like the proposed development is toward the southern end of Moosehead Lake. Can you see this part of Moosehead Lake from Barren Mountain, White Cap, the Bigelows, or any other AT high point nearby? (Views from the AT are not my only consideration when looking over this proposal, but it's definitely the thing that comes to mind first.)

ryan207
10-28-2006, 11:35
On a clear day you can see a lot of the state from the higher elevations. I was hiking the Bigelows in August and I had a great view of Barren, White Cap, and Katahdin. Nothing that Plum Creek intends to do here in maine will help. It might create some temporary jobs in the North which would be great for the locals, but in the end the result is just wood sprawling. This development isn't for the maine people, it's for those who build summer homes that they visit once a year. I was looking at a map of the intended Plum Creek development and if my memory serves me correctly it takes away a big chunk of the wilderness. Views from the AT will change, another similar problem is the proposed windmill project on Redington, what an eye sore that would be...

weary
10-28-2006, 13:22
For those like me who don't know Maine that well, I looked it up in an atlas and the southern-most shore of Moosehead Lake is a 15 mile drive mostly north and a little west from Monson. Do you know, Weary, exactly where the land in question is (both the proposed development and the area with the conservation easement)? How close to the AT? And how visible the proposed development would be from high view-points on the AT in the vicinity?
The development is spread over 400,000 acres. The AMC/Nature Conservancy deal ensures that much of the area will be preserved after Plum Creek develops the prime lake and river shores. It also helps ensure that Maine will okay the Plum Creek proposal.

It's a complicated issue over which I have mixed feelings. I suspect that approval is likely, with or without this deal. But the deal greatly improves the likelihood of approval.

As someone commented, "I thought blackmail was illegal."

But even if the plan is rejected, Plum Creek is likely to get everything it wants with a series of smaller proposals.

The development itself won't be very visible from the trail. But it will impact a vast area of wild country and set a precedent for another 8 million acres of wild land now owned by potential developers. (They prefer to be called land investment companies.)

The positive thing the deal offers the Appalachian Trail is that it allows AMC to buy 28,000 acres between Whitecap and the 35,000 acre Namakanta Preserve to the north.

This AMC acquisition would add significant buffers to the Appalachian Trail corridor in the 100-mile-wilderness and create a solid block of protected land from Gulf Hagas to Baxter State Park -- and north from the park through Maine public lands and along the Allagash Wilderness Waterway, almost to the Canadian border nearly 200 miles to the north.

Weary

walkin' wally
10-28-2006, 14:35
Quote [Weary]

But even if the plan is rejected, Plum Creek is likely to get everything it wants with a series of smaller proposals.


That is exactly right. It is their land after all is said and done.

It is too bad there was not another entity back in the day to buy the land from the paper company. That paper company wanted a fiber source and a quick one-$hot windfall.

Quote [Weary]

The development itself won't be very visible from the trail. But it will impact a vast area of wild country and set a precedent for another 8 million acres of wild land now owned by potential developers. (They prefer to be called land investment companies.)



There are a lot of people watching this, although a proposed development on Burnt Jacket Mountain was turned down recently.



Anyone who has been to Greenville regularly over the last 10 - 15 years has seen that town change a great deal and very fast. Monson is changing too.