PDA

View Full Version : Another down or synthetic question ...



bhc4985
10-01-2007, 15:56
For the past few years ive been a big fan of synthetic materials. Despite being slightly heavier, they tend to be cheaper and more friendly to my allergies. But now with all the new technology, there is hypoallergenic down and its getting more affordable. Now to the actually gear in question. Im looking at buying a wind resistant, packable, and lightweight vest. The products Ive been looking at are the Mammut Stratus Vest - synthetic, 10 oz, Mont Bell Therma Wrap - Synthetic, 5.5oz or the Mont Bell U.L Down Vest - Down (obviously) 5 oz. I like the down vest the most comfort wise, but Im a little skeptical of its wind "resistance" and how it would handle really damp weather. Aside from using it for most of my local hiking in vermont, whatever vest I choose will probably accompany me to the cloudforests in south america, where I have been a few times and it is always damp and usually windy and fairly cold. The Mammut feels the most durable and wind resistant, but I know this can be misleading. Has anyone here used any of these vest or their jacket counterparts? Id like a little insight before I drop the money on one. By the way, I know there are a lot of other ideas out there, but these 3 vest happen to be on sale at stores near me right now for about half off the msrp for each. Thanks!

Appalachian Tater
10-01-2007, 16:04
FYI, "hypoallergenic down" has just been washed very, very well. Most people are not actually allergic to down or fur, they're allergic to dust, dander, and the waste products of small insects like dust mites.

Greentick18d
10-02-2007, 11:17
I have the jacket version of the Montbell down vest. The wind resistance of the material is great but there is no elastic/drawstring at the waist so that is a weak point. I am going to sew one on before hitting the woodline this winter. I did get sprinkled on for a minute or two with it and the DWR was fine but I dont think it would stand anything heavier. I love it so far.