I don't think the ride vs no ride is an issue. Regardless or whether they take a ride they will be hiking 2653 of the PCT. The bigger issue is what defines the trail. Take last year, is the frog detour or the original route the "OFFICIAL" route? Scott and Adam would likely argue that the original route is the only option. But you are violating the restrictions placed on the route and could be fined for violating. And the PCT was just rerouted in the area around the Suattle River, adding mileage. So any future hiker will have a longer official route. And fire closures are also problematic. Some would argue that you should violate fire closures on a record attempt. Should you?