YAMA Cirriform vs. TT Notch vs. SMD Trekker?

[phourgenres]

The only thing I can discern is that the Cirriform has the deepest bath tub floor, which is pretty great for wind resistance as well. The tarptent uses superior silnylon, so seam sealing is not required. Anything else?

[Franco]

The Notch does need to be seam sealed.
You can choose the partial solid inner for it if you like better wind protection.

franco@tarptent

[HeartFire]

LightHeart Gear? Solo or SoLong 6 - the silnylon has a higher waterproof rating and an 8 inch bathtub floor

[Tarpcamper75]

Ive got the notch, Im 6ft 1 and have a large neo air xlite. It does well in the rain, you do have to seam seal it. Vents well. My favorite part is having both sides open, great views.

[William36]

I have the trekker and think it is an amazing design. Very happy with it.

It is on sale for $175 right now!!!!!!

[FamilyGuy]

Protrail!

Just kidding. I would go for the Notch because of its modularity, apart from the fact that I am a Tarptent junkie.