PDA

View Full Version : Lightweight Cooking Project



nelsonone
07-08-2014, 12:02
I have been working on an ultra light cooking solution for a couple of years now and I am curious what your thoughts are? I have two versions one made from stainless steel (1.8 oz.) and a titanium version (1 oz.). Both versions are compatible with Sterno, Trangia Spirit Stoves and various pop can stoves. It is 3.5" wide by 3.5" tall. Right now I am working on bringing the Critter CR2 to the masses through Kickstarter, so if you would like to become a backer you can check it out here: http://kck.st/1ufT0vg

I do value your questions and comments.

276702767127672

HooKooDooKu
07-08-2014, 13:05
The look is nice and sharp, it's very convenient (quick and easy to use) and stores small.

But if you're trying to attract the ultra-light-weight crowd, I would think that you would have to make sure your stand is in the same weight class as some of the DIY examples you can find on the Zen Stove Pages (http://zenstoves.net/PotStands.htm). I don't know, but just looking at your stand, it looks like is is several times more heavy than solutions like the tripod stand shown at Zen.

Another issue I possibly see (based on what you've got shown) is the fixed height. You can readily see by your second picture how different stoves put the flame at different distances from the bottom of your pot. With a DIY contraption, you can modify the height of your stand. So I would think that at a minimum you might need to design multiple stands at various heights.

Finally, contour of the stove support seems to be very limiting in what stoves will fit. Yes, the 'typical' pop-can design fits. But there are many stove designs out there that use very specific drink cans that are not shaped like a typical pop-can design. Two that quickly jump to mind that don't look like they would fit this stand is any stove designed around a 5.5oz cat food can, as well as the 'BottleStoves' advertised for sale on this very web site.

Damn Yankee
07-08-2014, 13:52
I agree. It looks great and the weight isn't bad but, the height as fore mentioned may be a problem. A lot of the alchy stove need to have the pot on them for pressure to get the best results. It does however seem to fit the Sterno well. If you can do something with the height I think you will have something.

perrymk
07-08-2014, 15:17
I knew it looked familiar so I did a quick search. Your design is reminisicent of the old Sterno Speed Cooker.

27673

http://www.ebay.com/itm/VINTAGE-STERNO-USA-034-Speed-Cook-Stove-034-Portable-Outdoor-Picnic-Camping-Stove-/161341464416?_trksid=p2054897.l4275

I'm pretty sure I have one of these in my collection at home (I'm taking a short break at work right now). There a number of solutions to the pot height thing. It might even be easier to put in fold out stops or cross bars to raise and lower the burner instead of the pot

nelsonone
07-09-2014, 09:19
It is interesting that you found that. I must be too young to have seen one of these before. It looks like it is built heavy duty. Thank you for your replies. In my next design I will have to think through the height issue for each of the stoves.

Demeter
07-12-2014, 08:14
Great idea. Like the sterno and trangia application

leaftye
07-12-2014, 09:02
It's not for all types of alcohol stoves. That's okay. What I like about it is it gets the stove off the ground, or for some people, picnic table.

Wise Old Owl
07-12-2014, 09:02
I agree. It looks great and the weight isn't bad but, the height as fore mentioned may be a problem. A lot of the alchy stove need to have the pot on them for pressure to get the best results. It does however seem to fit the Sterno well. If you can do something with the height I think you will have something.

That's interesting, I have never heard that before... I thought the pressure was created by the preheat, liquid expands to gas with heat to create pressure - are you thinking the penny stove? The distance is critical to allow enough oxygen to burn and provide heat to the biggest surface on the bottom of the pot... that's why side burners take longer, less heat transfer as the center of the pot is kept cool when sitting on the stove.

rocketsocks
07-12-2014, 12:00
I have been working on an ultra light cooking solution for a couple of years now and I am curious what your thoughts are? I have two versions one made from stainless steel (1.8 oz.) and a titanium version (1 oz.). Both versions are compatible with Sterno, Trangia Spirit Stoves and various pop can stoves. It is 3.5" wide by 3.5" tall. Right now I am working on bringing the Critter CR2 to the masses through Kickstarter, so if you would like to become a backer you can check it out here: http://kck.st/1ufT0vg

I do value your questions and comments.

276702767127672
I think it's a great product with some cool design features, the weight and simplicity being key, however I think your price point is a little high, if you could get it down the say the $11 to $13 dollar range, I think you'd sell a lot more, but that's just my 2 cents. good luck with it, it is pretty cool.