PDA

View Full Version : Bear kegs, where to place them?



GaryM
01-19-2019, 22:35
So do you keep them next to you? 100 yards away? Hang in a tree? Tossed in a bush? I think I have done all those but still have no idea what is best.

Deadeye
01-19-2019, 23:11
I put them in the woods nearby, maybe 100 feet away. Best place is a flat area or depression with plenty of logs, rocks, blowdowns, etc. so the canister won't be able to roll downhill if a bear disturbs it. Mine have never been touched. Don't leave it in a stuff sack or pack, or attach anything to it such that a bear might be able to grab it and run off with it. A bear won't get in, but they can drag it so far that you have a hard time finding it.

Dogwood
01-19-2019, 23:14
Return it the owner to receive your deposit back. OR...


https://p2d7x8x2.stackpathcdn.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/Unknown-6.jpeg


https://p2d7x8x2.stackpathcdn.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/Unknown-4.jpeg

https://p2d7x8x2.stackpathcdn.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/Unknown-5.jpeg

https://p2d7x8x2.stackpathcdn.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/Picture167-1.jpg

Sarcasm the elf
01-19-2019, 23:30
So do you keep them next to you? 100 yards away? Hang in a tree? Tossed in a bush? I think I have done all those but still have no idea what is best.

Canisters should be left by themselves in a low-lying areas where they won’t roll away if knocked around by an animal. A Bear canister’s primary defense (if I can call it that) is that are designed to be a size and shape that bears can’t get a grip on, because of this they shouldn’t have any ropes, bags or other items tied to them and they shouldn’t be hung or wedged in a tree or under a rock; Doing any of these things can give a bear the additional grip or leverage needed for them to puncture through the plastic and tear the canister open.

MuddyWaters
01-20-2019, 05:46
15' from me.
With small pile of baseball sized rocks to throw

A bear can is not bear proof. It is bear resistant.
It is still up to you protect your food and discourage bear

LazyLightning
01-20-2019, 11:27
somebody on the trail this year was talking about how most people don't store/hang there food properly and how everyone should have a bear canister... I'm actually getting one so I'm all for them but I got to the campsite right before dark and she was all set up with her bear canister right outside her tent door, where it stayed all night. I couldn't believe it, talking about how good they are and how poorly people store their food on trail and then leaves the canister right outside the tent completely defeating the purpose.

Time Zone
01-20-2019, 14:26
somebody on the trail this year was talking about how most people don't store/hang there food properly and how everyone should have a bear canister... I'm actually getting one so I'm all for them but I got to the campsite right before dark and she was all set up with her bear canister right outside her tent door, where it stayed all night. I couldn't believe it, talking about how good they are and how poorly people store their food on trail and then leaves the canister right outside the tent completely defeating the purpose.
maybe not entirely.
At first blush, it seems foolish, but upon reflection, let's see - the canister is to prevent the bear from getting the food. That it is right outside the tent - the bear still can't get the food. So the purpose isn't being defeated. Now, if the purpose was to keep the bear away from the tent, yes, that's close to the opposite of what you want to do.

But what if the can was kept 50m away from the tent. Well, then the bear might work on it all night, undeterred. It might find some leverage against the lid, or a means to smash it against some rocks.

I don't know the answer but it seems to me that a case can be made to keep the canister close by enough so that you know if it's being messed with (and then go to drive off the bear), yet not so close that the bear would be a step away from messing with you as well.

4eyedbuzzard
01-20-2019, 14:43
A question for those who use bear canisters (I never have). Do you also store your garbage/trail food waste in it? All other stuff that have odors that might attract wildlife (toothpaste, toothbrush, cookware, etc.)? And not meant to be gross, but in another thread there was much talk about packing out used toilet paper as an LNT principle. Most bear experts agree that human feces attract bears. So would used TP (obviously bagged) go in there as well?

Dogwood
01-20-2019, 16:56
Garbage, no used TP(haven't carried any in 15 yrs, if you don't carry it in it doesn't need to be carried out), toiletries, toof brush, toof paste, small wheel floss, sunscreen, separately bagged DIY almond oil based bug juice w/ essential oils,...At resupply or when mailing boxes it's more efficient in regard to garbage disposal, reducing packaging waste, drawing odors, reducing waste wt, bulk of packaging, etc to get that stuff out of the way before on trail. It snowballs further into UL and LNT practices. Simpler less bulkier toiletries further reduced from travel size = less waste, less bulk = more volume in the bear can for food and smellies = less impact on wild critters = fewer negative wild animal encounters. Most times after a 7 day consumables carry all my garbage fits easily in a sandwich or snack sized Ziploc. It equals less to burn too so less campfire impact. It's about us humans behaving well not constantly bitching about how other species need to always adjust to our, sometimes reckless, behavior.

Dogwood
01-20-2019, 17:02
Cookware is kept well cleaned on trail. I sanitize all cookware with H2O2 or NaOCl every 2-3 wks. Ditty rag is washed on trail and at most laundry stops. Laundry detergent chosen is fragrance free. H2O is a great solvent. Cookware is kept separate in the empty pack. Pack is usually part of my sleep system if it's not bear bagged or stored in a bear storage bin.

Dogwood
01-20-2019, 17:06
Bear canisters/kegs are not only for protecting food from bears. If bears aren't a great issue or there are other bear protection food measures available I like the more stuff able much lighter wt 5 oz Ursack Minor for rodents and smaller animals.

Maui Rhino
01-21-2019, 01:24
During my three trips to the Sierra, I placed my bear canister about 20-25 feet from the front of my tent, with my stove and cook pot on top as a noise maker. I never had any bear encounters in some 40 nights on trail, but I feel very comfortable doing this in Black Bear country. I'd probably leave it further out if Grizzlies are around.

Sarcasm the elf
01-21-2019, 01:46
I
A question for those who use bear canisters (I never have). Do you also store your garbage/trail food waste in it? All other stuff that have odors that might attract wildlife (toothpaste, toothbrush, cookware, etc.)? And not meant to be gross, but in another thread there was much talk about packing out used toilet paper as an LNT principle. Most bear experts agree that human feces attract bears. So would used TP (obviously bagged) go in there as well?
I place a “smellables” in my canister, the same as the default advice give for bear bagging. I can’t speak to the TP question as it’s a practice I’ve never engaged in.

Slumgum
01-21-2019, 11:10
We live in an area of Virginia where bears are plentiful and their population is on the rise. I had a bear take my nearly full 50 gallon compost bin and carry/push it over 200 yards from its original site (not downhill). The bear never accessed the contents. So I am more than a little surprised that bear canisters can be simply left on the ground with the expectation they will not be carried off. The more I read about handling food on the trail with regards to bears the less confident I become on the best approach to the problem.

GaryM
01-21-2019, 11:31
Great answers. I really like the idea of placing it not too far away in a depression. Harder to roll away but not too far to keep an eye on it.

Hikingjim
01-21-2019, 11:36
I put mine about 100-200 ft. Wouldn't want it to be so far away that I couldn't hear them working on it for hours.
Larger containers (such as coolers/bins) are easier for them to move further and pick up and throw around.

Can see a couple bear canisters mixed into this video
https://gearjunkie.com/bearproof-bear-resistant-gear-testing

and bear vault
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sn7oayAaf4k

martinb
01-21-2019, 14:06
A question for those who use bear canisters (I never have). Do you also store your garbage/trail food waste in it? All other stuff that have odors that might attract wildlife (toothpaste, toothbrush, cookware, etc.)? And not meant to be gross, but in another thread there was much talk about packing out used toilet paper as an LNT principle. Most bear experts agree that human feces attract bears. So would used TP (obviously bagged) go in there as well?

I FB cook so no odors from cookware (except small spoon which goes in the can). Any leftover bags/wrappers are usually burned. Toothpaste, brush go in the can. I bury everything, bathroom-wise, at least 200 yards from a campsite in a hole at least 8 inches deep.

As for can location at night, usually in some thick bushes or brush about 100 yards from the campsite. I have had a bear drag the can out from some thick bushes and move it about 15' or so in attempts to get into it.

StubbleJumper
01-21-2019, 16:10
I carry a bear can because it is required by regs, but if it wasn't required, I would just sleep with my food anyway. So, when make camp with a bear container, I usually sleep beside it and use it as a little night table. I need my comforts in the woods. :-?

steady123
01-21-2019, 17:25
I'd be afraid of waking up and the canister is "gone". What about attaching 25 ft of cord tied to a tree?

martinb
01-21-2019, 17:39
I'd be afraid of waking up and the canister is "gone". What about attaching 25 ft of cord tied to a tree?

A bear is not going to waste time batting your can around for hundreds of yards. As long as it's not in danger of dropping off the hill/Mt the can should not be moved far from where you placed it. Here's a shot of my can after it was moved about 15' out of some thick bushes just to the right.

44522

Deadeye
01-21-2019, 22:57
I'd be afraid of waking up and the canister is "gone". What about attaching 25 ft of cord tied to a tree?
Aside from the possibility of having a bear tangled up in cord, it may also give the bear something to grip, and drag your canister further than he would normally bother with. If Mr. Bear finds you canister, he tries to get in for a while, gives up and looks for an easier meal - it's sized so he can't fit it in his mouth. The worries are overblown, I've been using bear vaults for years for hiking and for food caches... it's never been touched.

QiWiz
01-24-2019, 17:06
I put them in the woods nearby, maybe 100 feet away. Best place is a flat area or depression with plenty of logs, rocks, blowdowns, etc. so the canister won't be able to roll downhill if a bear disturbs it. Mine have never been touched. Don't leave it in a stuff sack or pack, or attach anything to it such that a bear might be able to grab it and run off with it. A bear won't get in, but they can drag it so far that you have a hard time finding it.

+1 the key is a location that a bear is unlikely to be able to intentionally or accidentally relocate your canister so that it is hard to find.

scope
01-24-2019, 17:52
I like having it within sight distance and with some loose change thrown in to alert me when its being rolled around - I like to watch. At least that way I know what direction it might get rolled.

perdidochas
01-24-2019, 19:32
So do you keep them next to you? 100 yards away? Hang in a tree? Tossed in a bush? I think I have done all those but still have no idea what is best.

I misread the title as "beer kegs" and I was going to suggest putting them in a 55 gallon garbage can filled with ice in the shade. I was thinking that you are getting ready for a very generous hiker feed.....

Sarcasm the elf
01-24-2019, 19:39
I misread the title as "beer kegs" and I was going to suggest putting them in a 55 gallon garbage can filled with ice in the shade. I was thinking that you are getting ready for a very generous hiker feed.....

You’re in luck! Many models serve dual purpose!

44538

fishbone421
01-28-2019, 10:52
I had one bat mine around one night in shining rock wilderness area. Someone suggested i put reflective tape on it. The kind you use for trailers in white and red is what i used. Used a flashlight and made it much easier to find in the early am darkness.