PDA

View Full Version : Scotchguard



Bubblehead
03-14-2019, 07:49
Has anyone ever used Scotchguard on their backpack before, and did it work? I am planning to ditch my backpack rain cover this year, and I'll, as always, use an industrial garbage bag inside my pack...

Time Zone
03-14-2019, 08:23
I've not had great experience with spray on waterproofer, whether that brand or others. The points of weakness include zippers and stitching, but mostly I think it's the flexibility of the fabric: you're not really putting a flexible coat of sealant on there like polyurethane. Water splashed on it will bead up, but a steady rain will work its way through over time, IMO.

One critique of the compactor bag inside the pack method is that a soaked backpack weighs a lot more than a dry one (DCF packs excepted), so even if it's not a matter of the important contents inside getting wet, you may prefer to carry the weight of a cover (all the time) versus the greater weight of a periodically wet pack. The counter to this is that pack covers don't work 100% because water wicks from the shoulder straps to the pack - only a poncho type setup will keep the pack and its straps fully dry.

Bubblehead
03-14-2019, 08:28
Thanks for the response TZ....makes sense...

MuddyWaters
03-14-2019, 10:42
I used to have a gallon of water proofer used to treat popup camper cotton tent fabric, (sidewalls) and army tents.

Never had a leak, or spot soak thru, leaving up for years in woods.

Took 24 hrs to dry, after painting on with paintbrush.

Dogwood
03-14-2019, 21:35
After cleaning gear I use either PFC FREE Nikwax TX Direct DWR Spray On, my currently preferred approach, or PFC FREE Grangers Performance Repel Spry(works well too!) ONLY on the outside of Dyneema packs and maybe non WP trail runners to gain greater WR. Keeps the material from absorbing as much water, ice, and mud.

https://grangers.co.uk/products/performance-repel-spraySG is a stain and DWR. It's not a WPer.

https://www.nikwax.com/en-us/products/productdetail.php?productid=265&itemid=-1&fabricid=-1


Backstory:
I've sprayed on a SG similar "WPer" on ONLY the outside of Dyneema or older lower $ packs to increase water resistance. I no longer use a DWR containing a Per fluorinated compound (PFC). Some versions can be lasting chemical water pollutants found even in Sierra backcountry backwaters. Environmental more responsible outdoor gear manufacturers like Patagonia, Gore and TNF are looking for alternative non PFC containing DWR's. Nikwax and Grangers have already made the move. Patagonia has taken steps. Dont fully know about Gore as it's not my preferred choice for WPing. TNF?

https://www.nikwax.com/en-us/environment/fluorocarbons.php
https://cen.acs.org/articles/95/i7/Gore-drop-waterproofing-PFCs.html

All these approaches dent waterproof. They contribute to water resistance.

FWIW, even after applying a DWR to the outside of Dyneema and beater packs I still like a pack cover SOMETIMES, if heavy prolonged rains are anticipated. I do it because I like having my pack on as much as possible and store stuff that I dont want or couldn't easily Ziploc from getting totally drenched on the outside of packs.

chknfngrs
03-15-2019, 10:44
I don’t use a rain cover and have never used a spray on like you’re talking about. I’ve had greatest success packing clothing in gallon ziplock bags, and my sleeping bag goes in its compression sack and rolled into a garbage bag. The rest of the stuff is destined for wetness

Dogwood
03-15-2019, 18:19
"I've not had great experience with spray on waterproofer,.."

Maybe because you expected full waterproofing?

Dogwood
03-15-2019, 18:20
I don’t use a rain cover and have never used a spray on like you’re talking about. I’ve had greatest success packing clothing in gallon ziplock bags, and my sleeping bag goes in its compression sack and rolled into a garbage bag. The rest of the stuff is destined for wetness

So you let your pack absorb water?

nsherry61
03-15-2019, 20:37
. . . I am planning to ditch my backpack rain cover this year, and I'll, as always, use an industrial garbage bag inside my pack...

So you let your pack absorb water?
I just hike and backpack with my poncho. Then it all stays dry and I can even get into it in the rain, under my poncho and have it stay dry. Ponchos rock!

Dogwood
03-15-2019, 22:03
Can you take a bra off without taking shirt off too? :p

Riocielo
03-19-2019, 06:33
Can you take a bra off without taking shirt off too? :pAbsolutely! [emoji846]

Sent from my SM-G965U using Tapatalk

rmitchell
03-19-2019, 14:22
But can you get it back on?

The pack, I mean.

rmitchell
03-19-2019, 14:33
But to the original question, yes I have used Scotchguard on a pack.

I had part of can leftover from spraying a truck seat and used it on my 40 year old pack. The pack material is old school courdura and the Scotchguard did a good job of adding a degree of water resistance.

I used it in addition to a sil nylon rain cover and using lightweight garbage bags for clothing and sleeping bag.

Analog_Kidd
03-19-2019, 20:51
I bought a Rustoleum product called NeverWet. It's a two part thing that you spray on the first can, then an hour later second coat with the second can. I bought it for my bee hives... The theory is a pest called a hive beetle can't climb up metal strip barriers coated with the stuff. We'll see.

Anyway, I've been thinking about painting it Onto my pack since I have extra left over. This stuff is supposed to be extremely hydrophobic. They also make a one part product designed just for fabric. o

Anyone ever try this product?

Dogwood
03-20-2019, 00:22
gonna Starry Night over the top?