Speer type hammocks vs. HH...comfort level???

[sirbingo]

I'm a happy HH owner and I seen how lots of people prefer the speer type of hammocks for one reason or another but I'm wondering just how comfortable are speer type hammocks when compared to the HH.

:-?

[neo]

I'm a happy HH owner and I seen how lots of people prefer the speer type of hammocks for one reason or another but I'm wondering just how comfortable are speer type hammocks when compared to the HH.

:-?


i have hammocks simular to speer and the hennessey hammock
for me more difference in style and design in than comfort for me:cool: neo

[sirbingo]

I like hammocks mostly for the comfort level.
I'm wondering if I should make a spear hammock on its improved comfort level alone...

[blackbishop351]

Just Jeff says his homemade Speer is more comfy than his HH. I just made a Speer type a few weeks ago, and they're on about the same comfort level as far as I'm concerned.

They each have their tradeoffs. My Speer type is more comfortable for laying longways, but a little cramped side-to-side. I could have made it wider, but it's already heavier than my HH ULB. On the other hand, the HH has plenty room width-wise, but is a little shorter.

Because of the differences, I've just ended up laying in the two differently - but overall about the same comfort level. They both also have good and bad features other than comfort, too. I guess I'll continue using both until I find that one has a clear advantage somewhere.

As always, just my .02 :D

[Spock]

I sold my two HHs because I did not use them after making my own. Whether you go with Speer's methods or just roll your own, hammocks are easy to make.

HHs are well worked out, turn-key products. No hassel, no learning curve. They may be the best way to get into hammock camping.

On the other hand, I prefer my MYOG hammocks because they are side entry. I can use them with or without the bug net, I can bail out on either side. And I can adjust the underquilt and/or the subhammock easier. That's pretty important at temps below 70 F.

The weight and other characteristics of a MYOG hammock are variable - depending on materials and design details. It is impossible to compare them side-by-side with HH.

[sirbingo]

Are there any instruction on the web for MYOG hammocks?
I'd like to take a stab at making one.

:D

[attroll]

Are there any instruction on the web for MYOG hammocks?
I'd like to take a stab at making one.

:D

Here is a link on how to fold one up.
http://www.hammockforums.net/forum/showthread.php?p=770#post770

Here is a link on how to whip the ends.
http://www.tothewoods.net/HammockWhipping.html

[Just Jeff]

1 - Get 10' of fabric from Walmart. Ripstop is most popular but it can be anything strong enough.
2 - Sew a hem around all four sides (optional if you're just testing...just be careful)
3 - Whip it or tie a knot in the end.
4 - Attach a support cord or webbing.

It's that easy.

As blackbishop said, I find my homemade Speer-types more comfortable than my HH BULA. Maybe a longer HH would be more comfortable, though - haven't tried it. I still take my HH when I'm in buggy weather.

[porkbutter]

Here are the instructions for a Speer hammock:

http://www.hammockcamping.com/Free%20Reports/SewingTips.htm (http://www.hammockcamping.com/Free%20Reports/SewingTips.htm)

You can get Ed Speer’s “Hammock Camping” book here:
http://www.speerhammocks.com/ (http://www.speerhammocks.com/)

Note the option of just buying the hammock kit, and saving the hassle of finding the materials. I would suggest whipping the ends instead of the end knots, as this makes it far easier to adjust the hammock to your own comfort, especially after a few uses. Even if you use your own materials, I would also recommend is the hanging strap and spectra guy line materials from Ed; these are my favorites.

[porkbutter]

Sirbingo,
2 things to add to my last post:
1 - I really like my Speer
2 - If you whip it instead of using the end knots, make the tarp about a foot longer, as a whipped hammock gains the amount of material that would otherwise be in the knot.

[sirbingo]

Thanks for Porkbutter!