View Full Version : Backpacks: internal or external frame?
grizzly bear 336
05-11-2010, 22:35
I have an older external frame pack that was given to me and I have a Texsport internal frame pack. Which one would be better for hiking short runs on AT?
Feral Bill
05-11-2010, 22:42
Try them both and use the one that's most comfortable and holds your gear.
scout005
05-12-2010, 02:25
I love external frames for on trail hiking. Keeps the load away from my back which means it's cooler, carries nicer with the frame and doesn't feel like a potato sack hanging off my shoulders. I only use an internal frame for off trail hiking.
FB and s005 give you good advice. One thing you might think about on the external frame pack. Older packs that were not made by the better brands didn't have great hip belts and shoulder straps. I custom made mine and installed them on my cheap external frame from the 1960's. I have all I need in a pack with the external frame.
modiyooch
05-12-2010, 07:29
my external pack doesn't need to be stored in the tent or suspended at night. My external pack has multiple compartments and everything has it's own spot. It has great suspension based on my hips and doesn't hang on my shoulders.
If you're not carrying a heavy load, an external frame pack will add several extra pounds to your load. It makes less sense to use one when your packing light. I use a small frameless pack for my 10lb load. Someone asked if it just rides on my shoulders. I unlatched the waist strap to see if that was true. I couldn't see much difference. I suggest for a more enjoyable trip, you aim for that kind of weight. You don't (and maybe in some places should not) have to reach it, just aim for it.
Daydream Believer
05-12-2010, 10:26
I've hiked with both now and a well fitted internal frame pack is much nicer for me.
Try them both and use the one that's most comfortable and holds your gear.
What he said. Whatever pack is more comfortable for you to carry is the one you should carry.