Originally Posted by
blue indian
I went through the same process you are going through now except I spend way too much money ordering and returning packs. I bought and returned all of the following: osprey aether 60, osprey talon 40, ula circuit, gossamer gear mariposa (new model), and the granite gear blaze ac 60. I like certain features and fit of all of the packs I just listed but could not find the balance between features, comfort, and weight that I felt suited my needs.
Then I found out about elemental horizons and sprang for a kalais. I got one custom made and added a hipbelt pocket. I cant say enough good things about Matthew over at E.E and his customer service and willingness to do custom work. You wont be disappointed.
As far as the kalais vs circuit goes, the thing I like about the kalais over the circuit is the stay system. The single aluminum stay going down the middle of the back on the circuit just didnt feel right to me. The kalais has a "V" shaped stay which I found more comfortable. I also like the compression system of the kalais better than the circuits. Also I believe the kalais is slightly lighter than the circuit.
That being said, ula makes awesome gear too and comes highly recommended as well. It honestly comes down to personal preference and fit.