Originally Posted by
Jake2c
Wyoming, it is an interesting discussion. Personally I see a very big difference between sleeping in a bed and in a tent or hammock. Since people are free to pick either and comfort will drive out a choice that is not working, and hammocks are a choice people freely choose, I suspect there is a reason other than just a fad. Based on that, I did some personal testing. There are times when a tent is a better option but the opposite is also true. I have tent camped many more years than hammock camped but even with my year or two of experience in hammocks, I have been able to stop when tired to hang anywhere, when I would have kept walking with my tent. Hammocks have changed significantly over the past few years, my rain fly has doors that can close in the ends or be left open. Prop up one end of the rain fly and cooking is easy as I sit in the hammock with the roof of the fly being high enough not to worry about setting myself on fire. I have cooked in the vestibule of a tent but only with extreme caution and never with someone else stopping by to cook. I have had tenters come over to sit under my raised rainfly just to cook or to talk. Not the best at it but you can go to ground in a hammock where there are not trees or rocks suitable to hang from, but in general I would rather have a tent in those scenarios. If I am camping with a dog or my wife I also prefer a tent. I am older, and in my late 50's which may be the reason but I always sleep better in a hammock then on a matt in a tent. I have a small tent for backpacking so peeing in it is just about as much fun as peeing under my rainfly on a hammock. It is a little more work in the hammock but on the other hand, I don't have a bucket of pee in my hammock. If I am car/tent camping and can use a big tent then of course it is easy to pee, I can stand up in that tent, and I have a cot to sleep on. My backpacking tent is pretty good at keeping me dry if it doesn't start raining before I pitch the tent. On the hammock I put up the rainfly first when it is raining and then the hammock so I stay dry (reasonably dry). I hang my wet clots outside the hammock but under the tarp so I don't bring that moisture in with me. I put up my outer cover on my tent first when it is raining which helps when I use a tent. If you have ever done that, you know the challanges but it's doable. Two things are a fact for me though with respect to weather. It is harder to stay warm in a hammock so if it is cold, you need to prepare carefully. Of course if it is hot that can be a plus. The other thing is that when it is raining, I may have stayed dry in my tent but the next morning when I pack up I have to work carefully to not get everything muddy as I pack up a wet tent and muddy footprint. The hammock is never muddy unless I drop it. Rainfly will be basically clean but wet, I keep that in a separate waterproof bag. I am not trying to convince anyone to only use a tent or a hammock, but I do like to try and put out some of my real world experiences without knocking either option as they both have their strong points. That along with everyone else's helps people make informed decisions on the circumstances they will be facing on the trail of their choice. Heck, pulling a trailer behind me would be the most comfortable and I used to have one for many years out in Ca where I could drive to many fairly remote sites (lack of trees and a good 4x4 help with that), but that won't work on the AT for obvious reasons, I certainly would not say that trailer camping is not a good way to go given the correct circumstances. Bottom line is, if I don't mind going to ground in a hammock, I can camp pretty much anywhere, but if I was going to be on the ground more than 10-20% of the time, I would take my tent for the extra room and comfort for that scenario. Hammock on the ground is like a very small 1 person tent. If there is a lot of growth (trees or in jungle/swampy conditions) I would use a hammock. No tool does everything well. What ever keeps the adventure alive in your life is the best option.