Tarp and tent is overkill. Trekking poles useless as multi use item on Llbean fs tents. Pad for sleeping bag only pad needed. I have the fs1... mainly because I live in Maine. I am happy with it. I think I could have done better. It was a quick purchase on my part made out of necessity.
The good thing about a true free standing tent is that it can be fully assembled in a shelter and then drifted to a spot away from the shelter. I have done this in the rain. It makes setup nice in the rain. The bad about setting a fs tent up in the rain is that you cannot set up the fly and then assemble the tent under the fly like with some other tents.