WhiteBlaze Pages 2024
A Complete Appalachian Trail Guidebook.
AVAILABLE NOW. $4 for interactive PDF(smartphone version)
Read more here WhiteBlaze Pages Store

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 1 2
Results 21 to 30 of 30
  1. #21
    Registered User colorado_rob's Avatar
    Join Date
    08-20-2012
    Location
    Denver, CO
    Age
    67
    Posts
    4,540
    Images
    3

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Dogwood View Post
    Individual and group situations are always in question! What part of the AT did your 4 kids and you do? What time of the yr was it? What was your group's avg daily mileage? How many hrs of the day on that 9 day trip were actually spent on the move?/how many hrs doing other non-hiking things? How did your family and YOU deal with the group logistics on that AT trip ie; on avg how fast does your family get moving in the morn(WHEN it's below freezing?), ages of kids, EVER been to GCNP previously? are you aware of water conditions at that time of the yr? How much time have you allotted for your GCNP trip? Seems you haven't done much research so far. Have you apprised yourself of the typical avg weather in March on NOT ONLY the N. Rim but also the S. Rim? Being from central Fla you need to be aware nights will be below freezing at BOTH the N and S Rims. Fairly certain snow and ice will be on the ground at the N. Rim in the vicinity of the N Kaibab TH. It is not unheard of for ice and/or snow to some degree to exist at the S. Rim in March. Patches of ice, maybe snow linger in shady areas at the rims and to some degree on the trails into April which slows travel especially needed with 5 children in tow on possibly steep trail. No services or motor vehicle access will be open at the N.Rim so as it's been said it's a rim to rim to rim excursion you're looking at.

    Unless you and you're family, which includes 5 children, I'm assuming all/mostly adolescents, that's a 7 person party, are exceptionally above the avg in that family situation, I would not advise doing much more than 12 mile days going down to the river from the S. Rim and certainly not heading back up. What others do is one thing and you would be best to consider your situation in all your planning rather than what is appropriate for others. I agree with Shutterbug and would advise it to the OP: "... in most years an experienced hiker can do a rim to rim to rim in March, but I question trying to do it with 5 kids as a first hike in the Grand Canyon. For first-time hikers in the Grand Canyon, I recommend..." something else in March.
    `12 miles? It's like 7 from the SR to the river via the Kaibab trail, another very easy 7 to CW camp. Very easy 14 total miles, even with 5 experienced rug-rats. I do agree though that hiking from CW camp all the way to the SR would be a stretch for 5 kids... I guess I missed the 5-kid thing. I still think first night at CW camp is doable, with some other alternative for last night, closer to SR, like maybe that clear creek area. I'm just excited about first timers seeing the North Rim trail above CW camp; my favorite trail in the Canyon.

    Also: Agree, It will definitely be very cold on both rims at night, precisely why I discourage camping on either rim. Anything low-ish in the canyon should be nice and warm, especially of course the bottom (Phantom and those other places mentioned). Also Cottonwood camp; should be nice and warm there.

    Also agree there will probably be leftover snow and a tad of ice on the shaded upper south rim trails. Gone entirely in the 1st mile or so.

    Finally: PLENTY of water all throughout the main GC corridor. Plenty of TAP water, in fact. In 14 years running the water in the residence above CW camp has only been off once. We always carry tablets as a backup, used them precisely once in 14 years. The creek will of course be flowing like crazy that time of year.

    Shutterbug: we're doing early April this year (2016), it flip-flops from late March to early April. I think this time frame is the absolute BEST time to visit the inner canyon. Tons of daylight and not too hot yet, though we have had 90's at Phantom in early April. Most years it's 80's at the bottom then, very pleasant.

  2. #22
    GSMNP 900 Miler
    Join Date
    02-25-2007
    Location
    Birmingham, AL
    Age
    57
    Posts
    4,861
    Journal Entries
    1
    Images
    5

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by colorado_rob View Post
    Also: Agree, It will definitely be very cold on both rims at night, precisely why I discourage camping on either rim. Anything low-ish in the canyon should be nice and warm, especially of course the bottom (Phantom and those other places mentioned). Also Cottonwood camp; should be nice and warm there.
    I did a trip down to BA Campground with my kids over spring break (late March) two years ago. Weather seemed 'typical' (i.e. not extreme conditions). We experienced sleet and light snow fall on the South Rim the night before our hike. Temperatures were certainly below freezing as we started down into the canyon the next morning.
    (Temps at BA campground were great).

  3. #23

    Default

    I much prefer, and think it wiser, to err on the side of restraint given all I've heard from the OP hence that daily mileage rec FOR THEIR trip. Given more details I'd be open to changing those recs.

    It depends on easy as that is subjective although you are correct in saying the shortest trail distance from the S. Rim is from starting at the S. Kaibab TH to Cottonwood CG is 14.2 miles. That comes with conditions though. The S. Kaibab is shorter but also steeper. Some steps too some deep ones at that. With possible ice patchy snow on this steeper descent it would not be my personal rec given a family of 7 with 5 adolescents from FLORIDA on their first trip to the Grand Canyon allowing for lots of the ensuing oooh ahh factor. Even though the top 1 mile or so of the BA is shaded and often will hold some patches of ice and snow it's longer but more gradually graded making the trek from Bright Angel TH at the S. Rim to Cottonwood CG 16.7 miles. More than I'd rec based on what's been shared.

    While there will be water some of the tap water spigots are seasonal turned off usually between sometime in Nov to sometime in Mar.

  4. #24

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by colorado_rob View Post

    Shutterbug: we're doing early April this year (2016), it flip-flops from late March to early April. I think this time frame is the absolute BEST time to visit the inner canyon. Tons of daylight and not too hot yet, though we have had 90's at Phantom in early April. Most years it's 80's at the bottom then, very pleasant.
    I also like March, but I actually prefer November. I am taking three grandsons to Ribbon Falls next week -- my 32nd time to the bottom of the Canyon. This year, I hiked in March and April. Both were great. Last November, I did a rim to rim to rim.

    I avoid December thru February due to icy conditions near the rims. I avoid May thru Sept due to heat and lightening; however, one of my favorite hikes was in June. We hiked from Bright Angel to Indain Garden at night.
    Shutterbug

  5. #25

    Default

    http://www.nps.gov/grca/planyourvisi...-condition.htm

    Scroll to the bottom of the link and work off the avg temps at the N/S Rims and Inner Canyon in March.

    Heck, preferred times are mid March -mid/late June and mid Sept -late Nov/Dec(spent AWESOME Christmas at Phantom Ranch once) but I'll take the GCNP any month I can get there. I've had enjoyable trips Jan and Dec and during the height of summer. I like the heat though. During winter, winter skies over the GC, marginal permit competition, less/no crowds(on non corridor trails), while having the ability to descend through possible snow/ice into IMO IDEAL inner canyon hiking weather is phenomenal!

  6. #26

    Default

    Echoing what others have said: if at all possible, I would do low mile days.

    In my opinion, the Grand Canyon can be much, much tougher than the A.T. Descending is fine, but then you have to climb back out. And this involves thousands of feet of ascent.
    (trailname: Paul-from-Scotland)

  7. #27
    GSMNP 900 Miler
    Join Date
    02-25-2007
    Location
    Birmingham, AL
    Age
    57
    Posts
    4,861
    Journal Entries
    1
    Images
    5

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by futureatwalker View Post
    In my opinion, the Grand Canyon can be much, much tougher than the A.T. Descending is fine, but then you have to climb back out. And this involves thousands of feet of ascent.
    If you're an experienced hiker, it's just something you have to take your time with.

    When I hiked the South Kiabab down and Bright Angel back up the next day, I had a BMI that put me in the obese category, and my backpacking experience was limited to weekends in the Great Smokey Mountains where I typically limited my hikes to about 8 miles per day. I took my 7yo (who had 1 year experience backpacking with me) and my 11yo (who had 4 years experience backpacking with me). The morning of the hike back up, the 11yo was vomiting (I feared a stomach virus, but must have been some food poisoning).

    With that kind of experience, we were able to do the 7 mile hike down in 6 hours, and the 9 mile hike back to the rim the next day in 9 hours.

    The OP sounded more experienced and more prepared than I was, so I was thinking she might be able to make the hike to Cottonwood in one day. But that does make for at least a 14 mile trip in one day. So it really depends upon what the OPs experience really is. She said that she did 9 days on the AT. If that was 9 days averaging 10 mpd in GA, TN, NC area... then I think she might be ready for this 14 mile trip (but you better get up early in the morning you have to hike from Cottonwood back to the South Rim). But if that 9 days averaging 6 mpd in MA, Cottonwood is likely out of reach.

  8. #28

    Default

    One person's definition/opinion of experienced hiker does not always match others. The ranks are reduced of who's experienced when you consider a 6000 ft + steep elevation gain/loss that is rather relentless over 7 miles. When one hasn't been to GCNP and experienced that in March it should go without saying, uhh, that individual or group is inexperienced with that.

    How well does that compare to an AT hike even in the hardest 7 mile stretch during late spring /fall hence my questions to the OP?

  9. #29
    GSMNP 900 Miler
    Join Date
    02-25-2007
    Location
    Birmingham, AL
    Age
    57
    Posts
    4,861
    Journal Entries
    1
    Images
    5

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Dogwood View Post
    One person's definition/opinion of experienced hiker does not always match others. The ranks are reduced of who's experienced when you consider a 6000 ft + steep elevation gain/loss that is rather relentless over 7 miles. When one hasn't been to GCNP and experienced that in March it should go without saying, uhh, that individual or group is inexperienced with that.

    How well does that compare to an AT hike even in the hardest 7 mile stretch during late spring /fall hence my questions to the OP?
    Because every hiker's experience is different, I'm trying to give as much detail as I can about my situation so the OP has some basis for comparison.
    I found that my hikes in the mountains of GSMNP did a lot to help prepare me for GCNP, because the two have similar changes in elevation.
    The South Rim is around 7,000' and the Colorado river is about 2,500'; where as Fontana Lake is about 1,700 and the highest GSMNP peaks are around 6,500'.

    BTW: The actual distances/elevation changes for a South Kiabab to Cottonwood hike are:
    4,780' decent over 7.0 miles followed by a 1,600' ascent over 7.2 miles.

    While I was definitely sore after hiking the GC, looking back, I think that back then I could have make the hike from the South Rim to Cottonwood in one day. What I'm not too sure about would be Cottonwood back to the South Rim in one day.

    If spots are available, perhaps something a little more doable would be South Rim to Cottonwood, Cottonwood to Indian Gardens, and then Indian Gardens to South Rim. If the distance can be managed, don't finish on Bright Angle, but instead hike Tonto Trail from Indian Gardens back over to South Kaibab. (To the extent you can trust a profile in Google Earth, the path is about 4.5 miles long from Indian Gardens to Tipoff on South Kiabab, with a cumulative elevation loss of 800' and a cumulative elevation gain of 1,100'.)

  10. #30

    Default

    Just trying to provide helpful info for the OP -- In planning for hikes in the Grand Canyon take into consideration the duffle service that is available between the South Rim and Phantom Ranch. It is expensive, but worth the cost, particularly on the hike out. One can send up to 30 lbs up or down on a mule.

    When I do a rim to rim to rim, I carry a full pack only between Phantom Ranch/Brighr Angel and Cottonwood.
    Shutterbug

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 1 2
++ New Posts ++

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •