There was a lot of talk about which trail to take at the end of my hike - the Lordsburg route or the Columbus route. I started this thread to give me two cents on the subject as I couldn't find anything to really satisfy my curiosity.
I was at a time constraint at the end of my hike and decided to go the Columbus route, unlike many of my other fellow hikers (who were scattered a day or two behind or in front, the usual). I read that this route, plainly put, sucks. With that said, I have to say I enjoyed it. Here's why:
1. Deming, although small, was quaint and people were friendly. I met a guy in town who let me stay at his house for my layover night (as you can take a bus from Columbus to Deming and vice versa).
2. There are still some beautiful spots to be seen, even though there is a lot of roadwalking. But by this time you'll be use to it.
3. The most important: Southbounders headed to the Lordsburg terminus (with its cool obelisk) hit that spot and have to have a ride set up or face hiking back to the town. You see a fence, and your hike is over. Having a card passport, and heading the Columbus route, gives you the opportunity to walk into Mexico - which is exactly what I did. Palomas is the name of the border town, and after entering it I found a nice restaurant that served margaritas and by far the best burrito Ive ever had. This is such a treat for those who want that feeling NoBos get when walking into Canada. Even better, the bartender asked if I was a long distance hiker and proceeded to buy my meal and drinks (dunno how often he does this, but it happened and it was an amazing way to end with such special trail magic).
4. You can catch a bus from Columbus OR Deming to El Paso, which is a pretty booming airport that can take you home. My plane ticket from El Paso back to Louisville, KY cost me a total of $250.
I just wanted to share my experience, and if you see the last tree in the desert on your left (probably a day before you finish), check inside the tree.