Or something similar with the following stickied threads:
1. There is no best shoe --it really does depend on your feet.
2. How warm is that bag/quilt /- and what ratings mean, what you will really need.
3. How often is resupply possible and why you shouldn't carry extra food.
4. Yes. You need to filter or purify your water and you need to carry more than just a liter.
5. All about hiking poles and your knees.
6. 36-40 lbs is not ultralight. All about through hiking, weight and likelihood of injury and finishing.
7. No. You can't just kick a cat hole in the side of the hill in many places. You need a trowel.
8. Which pack is the best (and what size should I get) -- it all depends on your body build and preferences,
9. Etc.
Lifted from another thread, but it would make a good sub-forum for a set of stickies on often asked questions.
Just a thought.