For a winter top-level base layer, I've concluded that Merino long-sleeved hiking shirts are not for me. Why? They cause itching on my arms, centered on the inside of the elbow and spreading up but mostly down the arm. I'm satisfied with their wicking capabilities, but I can't deal with the arm rash. I"m pretty sure that Merino is the culprit - the reaction is quite noticeable after a few hours and I haven't gotten the itches when wearing anything else.
Are there any alternatives to Merino that still wick well? On today's hike, I wore my long-sleeved Gander Guide shirt. It's nylon and polyester, wicks, is comfortable and perfectly adequate for a day hike, but I'd like something warmer.
I found some good info. on this thread but I'd like to hear more.