Originally Posted by
Coffee
I think that's the point of his question, if I'm understanding correctly. It's the age old business question - what's the shape of the demand curve. And it is a hard business because the more affluent older people, like many retirees, will opt for private accommodations and the younger people are very price sensitive. One thing going for him might be a location early in the trail for NOBOs so most will still have money.
Personally I will stay in well run, clean hostels and I'm willing to pay around $30 at the most for a bunk, wifi and shower and expect to pay more for laundry, shuttles, food, and everything else. If I have to pay substantially more than $30 for a shared lodging, I'm very likely to seek a private room even if it is twice the cost or more. In other words, I have the money for private lodging but like to save some money when I can, but it has to be substantial enough to make sense.
$45 isn't bad if it is a well run hostel and you get laundry (worth $5) and a very good breakfast (worth $10+). In that case, the bed itself is valued at around $30 which is fine for a climate controlled clean hostel that isn't terribly noisy. IMHO.