I have been using frog toggs rain wear but my current set is starting to get tattered so I am deciding if I should get another set.

Frogg toggs are always hot for me at least down to low 40's. Have not had the opportunity to wear them in colder rain. They do provide good wind protection so that is a plus I have been using them along with one or 2 long sleeve shirts when windy and stay warm.

so would a tarp poncho provide as good of wind protection and rain protection? Can you button them down enough to stay warm in cold wet wind? I think in warmer conditions they would provide better ventilation than frog toggs.

I also like the idea of a spare tarp you could easily set up for cooking on warmer day when you don't need to wear it.

Would they be good at replacing my frogg toggs and provide other benefits?

What would you recommend? if you like them instead of a rain jacket?

PS I am big guy, but only 5-10 if that affects how they would work. Size XL in the Frogg Toggs.