Relax Jack, the comment about veteran thru-hikers was not a shot at you, OK, so don't be defensive? Not everyone here is trying to pick a fight with you. Did you not see the smiley face? My point was simply that if all the guidebooks printed that the campsite was no longer open, most first-time hikers would probably abide, but you've always got a few old timers who are gonna have a hard time following NEW RULES when they have fond memories of how things used to be. Didn't have anyone in mind.
As for the 2nd part, again, not sure you understood me. I wasn't blaming any of the guides, nor have I seen any of them in the last couple years. I also wasn't blaming any local officials. Simply, IMO, the authors should start printing that camping is prohibited, if that is what the townsfolks want. Because of recent issues, the place should be closed. I'm glad to hear this location doesn't have a history of being trashed, but it seems welcoming hikers to camp on the edge of town may yield issues and the seasoned hiker should figure out how to get thru town without this spot.