Originally Posted by
Hosaphone
I feel obligated to plug waterproof rain mitten shells. Have never understood why everyone doesn't use them. I have the MLD Event mitts, have heard good things about the Zpacks Cuben ones. Just something light and waterproof with no insulation.
They weigh ~1oz and IMO are 100% necessary if you plan to use trekking poles when it's cold and rainy. Keep your hands warm and dry when it's snowy and avoid getting your insulating gloves/mittens soaked. They will add a lot of warmth if you wear them over your gloves, which I guarantee you will appreciate in mid-march in the mountains...
Have you done much hiking in these yet? Most of the ultra-super-crazy distance people (Skurka, etc) wear regular shoes for a reason.
Just something to think about. I know people have done the trail barefoot, and I personally know someone who thru'd with 5 fingers. It is certainly doable. I'm very into minimalist shoes and they make short hikes so much more enjoyable, but for a thruhike I'd probably stick with trail runners. But again that's just me. Your mileage may vary. Anyways there will be plenty of opportunities to switch them out if you find your feet getting too beat up.
He has a $100, 550 fill power, "20 degree" bag. The bag actually has pretty good reviews online and it is heavy which in this case is a good thing... maybe it is true to its rating. But I think I would lean towards keeping the long johns at least to start with - more to supplement the bag than to hike in. Plenty of chances to mail them back if it turns out he doesn't need them.
What's your logic for 1x Nalgene and 1x disposable bottle?