JHG - Consider what you are wearing them for and what level of gaiter you would want. Yes I wore them - but not the big annoying ones. I wore the Mountain Hardwear Ankle high running gaiters - they stay attached to your shoe via velco (I buffed it up with some super glue). They kept debris out of my shoe and kept ticks from getting in my socks as much. It did not provide any water repellant but that was not the desire or need as my feet would still get wet. And if your knee deep in mud - who cares... ha. I liked having them as they kept the crap out of my socks - which are very important to your feet. Clean feet = Happy Feet