I'm agonizing over my outer/rainwear choice, I have a new Frog togg top, 13.9 OZ, or a an 12 year old old Patagonia DWR shell, 17.6 OZ

I'm not looking for any warmth, just some rain resistance, and a windbreaker.

which will serve me best for a NOBO AT Thru hike FEB 29 start


Thanks in advance

V/r HT1