That's the kind of info that is helpful! I have tried Go Girl and P Style. Go Girl requires completely dropping your clothes because it is too flexible and collapses inside clothes (bad), and then is difficult to point away from them when the clothes are down around your ankles. It's really great on a boat, and I am a big fan of it in this instance. But for hiking, if you want to keep your clothes on, go with the P Style. Definitely practice at home first. It's great with pants or skirts that have a fly zipper, and just move underwear to the side. I read a suggestion of wearing men's boxer briefs, with a fly, and that might be a good option. Might check it out. But I really like my ex-officio underwear, which works fine with P Style.